Portfolio frames
The portfolio team's working picture for the next round: where the portfolio stands (ten clusters), where it is moving (ten spaces), the logics and enquiry areas from Budapest, and the candidate positions that came out of them. Open any card for its reasoning; the initiative graph is the full node-and-link view.
AI-generated by the portfolio team's tools and marked by them as a work in progress for human refinement — every card is a proposal until a named person confirms it. Extracted 2026-11-05.
Where the portfolio stands — ten clusters
P1Bioregions and Land
Active: Six projects: Transatlantic Bioregions in Ireland, Findhorn, North Carolina, Muga Valley, and Tayside; Catalysing the Two Basins (Amazon and Congo).
Why now: A governance and finance blueprint is being built across six anchor regions, with year-end recommendations for continued work in 2027.
Why us: Funding one partner would scale one capability or one place. The Collaborative orchestrates the partners across the sites with a learning thread between them, which produces a blueprint no single partner could.
Noticing: The bioregion, a landscape with its own ecological coherence, governance traditions, and economic possibilities, is the missing scale at which capital, governance, and ecological knowledge can be brought into coherence.
P2Cities and Urban Transformation
Active: Five projects: URBind; Porto Alegre Resilience Accelerator; COUGAR: Next Stage (QCF); African Cities Mission; Resilient Housing One-Stop Shop.
Why now: What is missing is the institutional infrastructure that turns plans into procurement at scale.
Why us: Urban climate work is fragmented. The Collaborative brings EU mission cities, Latin American demonstration, Global South housing, and African mission cities into one coordination layer.
Noticing: Climate commitments at municipal level have outpaced cities' ability to turn plans into implementation-ready, financeable projects.
P3Policy and Systems Change
Active: Four projects: Systems Transformation Hub 2026; Subsidy Transformation for Climate Adaptation; Policy Impact Labs: EU Policies; Policy Infrastructure / Mapping.
Why now: The difference between transformational and incremental policy outcomes is usually the institutional readiness to act when a window opens, and to keep that capacity alive when it closes.
Why us: No single partner has the Brussels office, the CEO network, the Global South policy research, and the systems modelling together. The Collaborative can act collectively inside a 48-hour policy window.
Noticing: Climate policy windows open and close unpredictably, and the EU political environment has shifted decisively against climate action.
P4Finance and Investment
Active: Two projects: Transition Studio; Securing Urban Futures and Security Financing.
Why now: Without new instruments, the gap between systemic ambition and deployable capital holds back every other position. Designing instruments before they reach the market is itself a leverage point.
Why us: Finance funders cannot pay for the slow language and policy work. Systems-change funders cannot pay for the technical instrument design. The Collaborative holds both.
Noticing: The financial system as currently constituted does not yet price ecological resilience, intergenerational continuity, or distributed stewardship.
P5Adaptation and Resilience
Active: Three projects: Beyond 1.5 Transformation Hub 2026; Resilience Supercharger 2026; Resilience Supercharger (QCF).
Why now: Communities need help to face difficult futures together, and capital and decisions need a route to the communities most at risk. The political and emotional capacity to face this honestly is itself the constraint.
Why us: It is one of very few vehicles working on transformative adaptation. No single partner could orchestrate it at this combination of scales.
Noticing: The world has breached 1.5 degrees, and adaptation is a primary site of transformation.
P6Circular Economy
Active: Two projects: Circular Supply Chain Coalition 2026; Catalysing the African Strategic Minerals Initiative.
Why now: Community-benefit architecture, just-transition negotiation frameworks, and African strategic leverage on minerals determine whether the transition minerals and materials economy emerges as extractive or as equitable.
Why us: No single partner could deliver this combination, at what is described as the politically hottest intersection in climate.
Noticing: The minerals, materials, and supply chains the transition needs are extractive in their political reality. Circularity matters most where extraction politics are fiercest.
P7Governance and Democracy
Active: Three projects: Guardians of the Future 2026; Democratic and Social Infrastructure (QCF); Partnership for Digital Justice (QCF).
Why now: This is the foundation that lets the rest of the climate work hold against political backlash, and most climate funders are not investing in it.
Why us: Climate funders usually separate democracy work from climate work and lose the connection. The Collaborative is one of very few vehicles working them as one.
Noticing: Climate policy that arrives without citizens' authorship gets reversed in the next election cycle, and transitions that bypass communities generate the backlash that fuels populist climate rejection.
P8Food and Agriculture
Active: No 2026 projects. Two projects ran in 2025.
Why now: Land, water, and food belong together as the first thing to keep attention on as the systems that protect people grow less reliable; food supply shocks are already visible, and the Ireland dairy work and smallholder networks in the Global South are the two live fields.
Why us: Systems mapping, Global South partner networks, and access to Brussels through the Systems Transformation Hub make the diagnostic credible with EU policy-makers and with smallholder farmer collectives.
Noticing: Many mechanisms for agri-food transition and agrobiodiversity already exist, but they are poorly coordinated and understood.
P9Learning and Capabilities
Active: Three projects: Symbiotic Partnerships (QCF); Power Literacy (QCF); Transatlantic Bioregions: Cross-Regional Learning.
Why now: Whether the Collaborative scales to €100 million a year as planned depends on whether the SymbiOS operating system, the Power Literacy capability, and the cross-bioregional learning thread work as designed.
Why us: No partner can build the operating system of the Collaborative alone.
Noticing: Most coalitions treat learning as a peripheral function: a report at the end. The Collaborative treats it as core infrastructure.
P10Narrative and Culture
Active: One project: Narrative Portfolio: Scaling and Activating.
Why now: The binding constraint on policy and finance in 2026 is the register in which the transition is publicly understood. Without benefit-led, culturally resonant narrative, the rest of the portfolio runs into a hostile public and a reversible political consent.
Why us: No single partner can integrate communications, arts-based engagement, and CEO-level influence.
Noticing: Fear-driven climate communication has failed across two decades.
Where it is moving — ten spaces
Ways of working towards change
ideasImagination, methods, and experiments
New paradigms, alternative futures, imagination, systemic experimentation, transformative practices, prototyping.
Clusters here:
powerPeople power and civic participation
People power, democratic participation, civic infrastructure, collective action, distributed agency, social movements.
Clusters here: Governance and Democracy
placePlace-based transformation
Bioregions, territorial transformation, regional resilience, local implementation, connecting place-based initiatives.
Clusters here: Bioregions and LandCities and Urban Transformation
Systems we might seek to change
materialTransforming the economic base
Production and consumption, industrial transitions, food and energy systems, circularity, material flows, supply chains.
Clusters here: Circular EconomyFood and Agriculture
valueMoney, value, and ownership
Alternative measures of value, new economic models, ownership and stewardship, finance, currencies, incentives.
Clusters here: Finance and Investment
livingLiving systems, health, and care
Ecological regeneration, resilience, and adaptation; biodiversity; planetary health; cooling; human wellbeing; care.
Clusters here: Bioregions and LandAdaptation and ResilienceFood and Agriculture
Enabling change
cultureCulture, narrative, and consciousness
Cultural transformation, imagination, worldviews, narratives, aspirations, relationships with nature, alternative conceptions of prosperity.
Clusters here: Narrative and Culture
knowledgeThe knowledge commons and learning
Distributed knowledge, shared learning infrastructure, knowledge commons, collective intelligence, solutions frameworks.
Clusters here: Learning and Capabilities
institutionsInstitutions, policy, and law
Institutional transformation, legal innovation, policy, democratic governance, multilateralism, institutional capabilities.
Clusters here: Policy and Systems ChangeGovernance and Democracy
technologyAI and technology
AI and its social consequences, distributed intelligence, digital and technological infrastructures, technological governance.
Clusters here:
Portfolio logics — Budapest Day 4 (29 cards across 7 logics)
Mind the Gap (Latching on to existing infrastructures)8 cards
The entry point is what is missing from the portfolio and from what has been discussed so far. Ideas surfaced bottom-up, and the thread that connected them was latching on to existing infrastructures: structures that already exist, such as the militaries, faith communities, energy communities, land, and food and water, whose capabilities are not yet used for good. Partner with them, or hack them. The Collaborative is under-baking people power, and could mobilise people en masse through culture and movement building. This is not a particularly coherent logic in itself; its initiatives sit inside the bigger portfolio. It also works as a standing gap-check, since whatever logic is used, some things will always sit on the edges. To move now, frame the ideas as learning hypotheses and assign scouts by who has the best network.
M1People power, culture, and movement building
Noticing: Counter-movements have nailed coherent, viral talking points that mobilise populations, and the field has not built movement tools at that scale; the Collaborative is under-baking how far it could mobilise people en masse. What is emerging is a constellation that could be framed together: energy communities, the Green Space initiative, faith communities, and the future of labour markets, with culture, the arts, and campaign tactics as the means.
Why now: Counter-movements have mobilised populations with coherent, viral talking points, and the transition field has not matched them. A large neighbourhood mobilisation is being designed for launch next year.
Ideas: The Green Space initiative and energy communities can be taken into existing work straight away with a tighter combined focus. Also: faith communities, the future of labour markets, culture and the arts, and campaign tactics. A scenarios approach to future lifestyles can support participatory foresight.
M2Partnering with or hacking the military
Noticing: Militaries are either planning for the write-off of significant parts of the population or know they will be overwhelmed by crises in food, energy, and water, and the transition field has largely not acted within them. The opening is that militaries carry exposure of their own and can make common cause on risk, peace-building, and climate, through procurement and provisioning, through retired actors, and through models such as the Jordanian guard.
Why now: Investment in military and security is rising across countries right now. Where defence spending drives change in a place, ignoring the defence agenda leaves the Collaborative irrelevant to that change.
Ideas: Partner with military actors, retired ones included, to make common cause on risk, peace-building, and climate action, with procurement and provisioning as a lever. Explore dual-use funding, such as rewilding peatlands as a defence measure, and start conversations through members' networks.
M3A food and water stability board
Noticing: International multilateral systems cannot be assumed to hold, and food supply is already breaking down, with fertiliser shortages, falling reserves, and the Strait of Hormuz. What is forming instead is multipolar: city-states and cities in bioregions hanging together in risk and in solidarity, which is where a food and water stability board, on the model of the Financial Stability Board, could latch on.
Why now: Food supply is at risk now, in light of events in the Strait of Hormuz.
Ideas: Set up a food and water stability board, modelled on the Financial Stability Board, possibly as a mid-tier structure of middle powers. Connect the bioregional and cities work to food and water security, urban farming, and biohubs. A Global Council on Ecological Stability and Justice is a broader model.
M4Faith communities
Noticing: Faith communities are an existing structure whose capabilities this work rarely engages, and the Collaborative has little capacity there so far. They hold trust and reach that the people power cluster lacks, so they sit inside it as an entry point.
Ideas: Explore people-determined contributions organised through faith communities, on the model of nationally determined contributions. Capacity in faith communities is small so far.
M5Energy communities and energy democracy
Noticing: Energy bills are driving people to anger, and the infrastructure they depend on is not theirs. Forming an energy community saves them money and provides a real infrastructure, an entry point for people power; the first task is to make one's own community work.
Why now: People are angry about high energy bills, and Europe already has a good legal framework for energy communities.
Ideas: Bring them into existing work alongside the Green Space initiative.
M6Land ownership as a restoration lever
Noticing: Who owns land decides what can be restored, and land ownership models are not foregrounded in the portfolio though many members know and work on them. Ownership models are a major structural shift already under way, one the Collaborative could latch on to.
Why now: Restoring degraded land at scale needs control of the land, and the time to reach 35 million hectares is short.
Ideas: Connect biohubs and bioregional restoration to the shift from ownership to stewardship, with rights of nature and an earth sovereign fund.
M7Criminal law
Noticing: Accountability efforts stop at civil liability, so criminal law, one of society's most powerful levers, goes almost unused in this work. The opening is in going after individuals and institutions alike, with ecocide as an international crime already in motion; penal liability could create a much greater fear of transgression.
Why now: Fossil fuels may soon be named as health-harming, ecocide is being pushed as an international crime, and live cases are showing how criminal law reaches the most powerful people.
Ideas: Explore criminal liability for fossil fuel harms, alongside the effort to make ecocide an international crime, and the role restorative justice and justice reform could play. Start by scouting the first three places to work, through members' legal networks.
M8Seeding doubt: investor awareness and risk appetite
Noticing: ESG ratings as currently structured let oil and gas companies score highly regardless of climate harm, so investment assumptions run on automatic. Doubt established officially and on the record, through challenges to prospectuses, double materiality reporting, and court findings, can block those assumptions and force risk onto the books.
Why now: A UK Supreme Court case has forced oil and gas companies to acknowledge climate risk in the prospectuses for new fields.
Ideas: Run a campaign for greater investor awareness that seeds doubt, officially and on the record, until it blocks and shifts automatic investment assumptions. Examples raised include challenges to oil and gas prospectuses for new fields, double materiality reporting, and how court findings feed risk analysis.
The macro frame from tipping points4 cards
A way of composing a portfolio that starts from where the global system is tipping. Negative tipping points, physical and social, show where risk cascades and where institutions are open to transformation; positive tipping points show where a shift, if activated, could lift towards new futures. Each is traced back to its drivers and to the places where it can be acted on, and that is where strategies are drawn from. The strategies can be grouped in many ways; the four buckets here are the example worked in the room. A filter for feasibility, capability, and budget then narrows them to positions, with options placed within them. The aim is combinatorial effect: initiatives chosen so that they intersect. Offered for the whole portfolio or a share of it, alongside the other logics.
T1Critical institutional transformation
Noticing: The institutions that hold the system, formal and informal, multilaterals included, become vulnerable under a sustaining crisis, and the WHO is already asking how to reinvent itself. That vulnerability is where they can be transformed, and where the informal can step in.
Why now: A major nutrition or health crisis would open a political opportunity to step into such institutions from the informal, so the question to ask in advance is where vulnerability will open up, to be ready to catalyse, move, and react.
Ideas: Examples: the WHO, vulnerable and ready for transformation; the fractal health infrastructure; the multilaterals.
T2New vectors of power
Noticing: Power over the levers that matter is leaving the institutions that held it, and many of the businesses and bodies the field works through may not hold the same power in five years. New vectors of harder power are forming: planetary civic movements, new political and business alliances, health and youth as constituencies.
Why now: Positioning depends on reading that shift: who has power now, who will have it in five years, and who needs to hold it going forward.
Ideas: Examples: new political frames and networks; businesses, health, and youth as vectors; reframing fossil fuels as health-harming.
T3Place-based proofs
Noticing: The locations of tipping points are not always where the battle can be won; around the Himalayan glacier cascade, political conditions block innovation. A tipping point that cannot be moved where it sits can be proven in a place where the conditions allow it, setting a precedent that can diffuse.
Why now: The locations of tipping points are not always where the battle can be won. Around the Himalayan glacier cascade, which affects 3.8 billion people, political conditions block innovation, so the move is to build the capability in a stable place and diffuse it. Land conflict is expected to accelerate as pressures rise, and a coming land renegotiation in Canada would set a precedent.
Ideas: Examples: fossil-fuel-free zones, or life zones; bioregions; a 1% global biodiversity trust; whole-economy work in places, a big bet.
T4Tooling and experiments
Noticing: A frame that starts from tipping points cannot see everything: blind spots and black swans will show as risks move, so one box stays empty on purpose. Tooling is where the underlying conditions get built: capabilities, new currencies, new contractual and rights frameworks.
Why now: A frame that starts from tipping points has to keep evolving as risks and blind spots show, so space for exploration and imagination is part of its design.
Ideas: Examples: a new currency; going beyond GDP; room to test tactics and make errors; a fund kept aside for risky, catalytic things not yet visible.
New System Design4 cards
Start by asking what the noise is, and what power structures hold the current system in place. Earth is a living entity that no one owns, with people as its stewards. Three positions follow: moving from ownership to stewardship, building an earth consciousness movement, and setting up an earth sovereign fund. At the centre is a new mental model, a different operating system for the earth, much of it anchored in the existing worldview of Indigenous nations. The choice is to start from the base of building something new. Much of the Collaborative's existing work fits the new system once it is reframed from the perspective of Earth.
E1From ownership to stewardship
Noticing: The power structures holding the current system in place rest on ownership, of land, of companies, and of ideas through corporate and IP law, and the noise tells people that ownership is what to seek, leaving them lost in a crisis of belonging and climate change. The alternative already exists: Indigenous nations hold stewardship, not ownership, of their bioregions, and the earth tells us we all belong.
Why now: The noise tells people what they need to be seeking, and they find themselves lost and disconnected, in a crisis of belonging and climate change.
Ideas: Options include rights of nature and ecological institutions, civic nature-data mechanisms, education and reskilling, and a peace-incentive complex. Some options, such as rights of nature and life-aligned AI, serve several positions at once.
E2An earth consciousness movement
Noticing: Systems are made of people, and the current one has left them isolated; the movement needs a crisis to start, as COVID was one. A budding earth consciousness movement is already under way, and an AI-enabled crisis of belonging could be the moment it catches.
Why now: The movement needs a crisis to start, much as COVID was one: an AI-enabled crisis of belonging, with AI emerging as a new form of intelligence.
Ideas: Work through arts and narrative, starting from where alternative systems already operate. Plant the new mental model through existing networks, framed as an opt-out from the current one, and connect it to the networks of Indigenous nations whose stewardship is already the alternative in practice.
E3An earth sovereign fund
Noticing: The global financial structure runs on nation-state currencies, and what really backs the US dollar is the military industrial complex. An earth sovereign fund would be the alternative: funds that no one owns, held in stewardship, able to finance the movement.
Why now: This moment is an opening to completely restructure how things are done, while the global financial structure still rests on national currencies and the military industrial complex.
Ideas: A fund needs rights of nature, civic participation, a data mechanism, and life-centred AI, with decisions made through a life-centred AI proxy. Also: a federated fund compiled from local funds, and using the fund to finance the earth consciousness movement.
E4Alternative money or an earth currency
Noticing: Money as it stands cannot see the earth it runs on. Alternative money would work with Earth as the treasury: a currency for the earth, alongside the earth sovereign fund.
Ideas: Develop earth money alongside the earth sovereign fund. Data as the new currency is one idea, because everyone has the same amount.
Ecology of Possibilities6 cards
The Collaborative's work is an ecology of possibilities that weave into each other: a tool for how members collaborate. Its purpose is to make the joint work as ambitious as it can be, bring members' capabilities together, and spot the gaps that stand between the Collaborative and the level, scale, and speed of impact. Six areas of intervention sit in three layers, a sandwich. Cultural and structural enabling conditions sit underneath. Orchestration of place-based action and transforming systems and industries sit in the middle, where tangible change happens. Transformative concepts and engaging power players sit on top and support the middle. Change is driven by the lines between the areas, the pipes and the flows, and the structure that carries them is the Collaborative itself. Every enabling condition and every concept also has a shadow side. A second map sets out the symbiosis of wholes and parts: the individual, the organisation, the Collaborative, the wider climate response system, and the world, with constant awareness of where a gain for one is a loss for another. It has to deliver against 40 gigatons and 35 million hectares. The question that remains: how to make sure the Collaborative is “a value add, not a time sink”.
X1Transformative concepts, methods, practices, and activations
Noticing: Members generate concepts, methods, and practices through their joint work, and these are rarely articulated or passed on. What is emerging is the sense that the concepts are what reach power players, citizens, and allies, and that some funders care more about them than about any one place or system.
Why now: The concepts are what reach power players, citizens, and allies, and some funders care about concepts and enabling conditions more than about any one place or system.
Ideas: Resource the articulation of members' concepts, methods, and practices, and collect members' knowledge into scenarios of possibilities that guide people's work.
X2Engaging power players, decision-makers, citizens, allies
Noticing: Lobbying and networking as usual have not shifted the decision-makers, citizens, and allies that change depends on. Engaging is the word, to honour their agency; funders and investors count among them, and a global governance model for natural resources is one thing engagement could build.
Why now: Without bringing these people on side, the rest of the work will not succeed.
Ideas: Influence power players to build a global governance model for natural resources. Investigative journalism, such as Global Witness's work, was named as a gap in the Collaborative.
X3Transforming industries and systems, the value chains
Noticing: Whole industries and systems, food systems and democracy among them, still run on extraction through production, consumption, and waste. The New Mexico circular supply chain work shows an industry being transformed through its value chain from a place: the worked example.
Why now: There is no global governance for materials and resources, although there is for climate change and biodiversity.
Ideas: Build on the New Mexico circular supply chain work, the worked example across the areas. Members also said work is needed on global material governance.
X4Orchestration of place-based action
Noticing: Action in particular places is often cut off from the institutions, infrastructures, and conditions it depends on. The energy for place-based work in the Collaborative is there right now and can feed the rest of the ecology, with the North Carolina work as the case.
Why now: The energy for place-based work in the Collaborative is there right now, and it can feed the rest of the ecology.
Ideas: Build on the North Carolina place-based work, which feeds a knowledge commons.
X5Cultural enabling conditions
Noticing: Mindsets, narratives, capabilities, and relationships are where change stalls when they are missing. As enabling conditions they set the pace, speed, and scale of the other areas and of the flows between them, and they sit underneath everything else.
Why now: Enabling conditions set the pace, speed, and scale of the other areas and of the flows between them.
Ideas: Exchange capabilities directly between members, such as mentorship on how to talk to funders and repeat runs of the AI masterclasses for the whole Collaborative. Build a narrative toolkit and facilitation capabilities for bioregions, shared through the knowledge commons, and collect members' foresight work into scenarios of possible destinations.
X6Structural enabling conditions, the infrastructures of transition
Noticing: The general systems that keep the world operating do not carry a transition. A transition runs on its own infrastructures, networks, knowledge systems and the commons, information systems and AI, money and currencies, institutions, policies and regulations, and with a global knowledge commons the flows between the areas would speed up.
Why now: Infrastructure is much of the answer to how the areas connect. With a global knowledge commons, the flows between them would speed up.
Ideas: Members gave examples: Strata, Dark Matter Labs' learning infrastructure; Funga, open to every member organisation; a global knowledge commons; and the Collaborative's operating system.
Transforming economies, cooling and caring2 cards
Focus on the essential: three fundamental things to do. Transform the economic base of the systems we are embedded in, making economies regenerative and circular, including disrupting the monetary system and the way value is attributed to nature and to human societies; the transformation of the economic system is the core of it all, what fuels climate change and the current crisis. And cool and care, because of the inevitable damage that cannot be avoided even if the work on the economy succeeds: heat in major cities, health problems, disruption of essential infrastructure. Cooling and caring ticks many boxes: everyone can relate to it, it can be sold to funders, and it connects with what people care about. Much existing work fits these two essentials; one move is to swarm one sector, fashion first, as a model for transforming the rest. The third essential is building the connective tissue of societies, and the global knowledge commons is the soil beneath all three.
K2Transforming the economic base, regenerative and circular economies
Noticing: The economic system is what fuels climate change. Regenerative and circular economies are emerging, and swarming one sector, fashion first, would show the economic base being transformed.
Why now: The economic system is where climate change and the current crises originate, so transforming it is the core of the work.
Ideas: Swarm one sector, first fashion, as a model for transforming the economic base.
K3Cooling and caring
Noticing: Cooling is built into every IPCC model, and even if the economy is transformed people will still suffer from heat, health problems, and disrupted infrastructure. Cooling and caring together is something everyone can relate to, and a heat-regulation architecture, measured in watts per square metre, is already being built.
Why now: Combining cooling with caring could bring a significant improvement in the quality of life for millions of people.
Ideas: Build on the heat-regulation architecture, measured in watts per square metre, which already has a five million dollar fundraising campaign under way.
Building the connective tissue of societies3 cards
The starting hypothesis: much depends on recreating the sense of common action that declining middle-space institutions used to provide. The question is how to build connected, local institutions and ways of working, lightly and peer to peer, that link existing civic action with the institutions that need to change. They should neither duplicate what exists nor become a new form of government. The focus is on connecting civic participation with current and emergent institutions, with the Hungarian Peace Islands work as an example, and on participatory governance as a way past stalled policy. Civic participation belongs as a must-have in every portfolio decision. Five enabling conditions for constituency power, a list still unfinished: knowledge bases, peer-to-peer learning across constituencies, financial flows, capacity and leadership, and mobilising faster around political windows.
K4Social infrastructure, the connective tissue of societies
Noticing: The middle-space institutions that gave societies a sense of common action have declined, leaving a gap between institutions and civic action. Societies need that connective tissue again, built lightly and peer to peer, without duplicating what exists or becoming a new form of government.
Why now: The middle-space institutions that once organised common action have declined, and alternatives need to be ready when political windows open.
Ideas: Build light, networked, local institutions and ways of working that join existing civic action to institutions without duplicating them, and bring international experience to Hungary as a flagship.
K5Connecting civic participation with institutions
Noticing: Civic participation and institutions have come apart, and institutional renewal without participation has no anchor. The Hungarian Peace Islands work shows participation connecting with current and emergent institutions, and civic participation belongs as a must-have in every portfolio decision.
Why now: Without high participation and real power in decisions, the transition is not fair. Youth participation in civic structures is low, and the people power narrative is being lost rapidly.
Ideas: Make civic participation a must-have in every portfolio decision, current or new, as a cross-cutting move.
K6Participatory governance as the way past stalled policy
Noticing: Policymakers are scared to take any transformative action, for fear of backlash, and the result is stalemate. Participatory governance is the key response, a new way of doing policy, with constituencies invested in so they are ready to shape emergent institutions.
Why now: Policymakers fear backlash and policy is in stalemate, so a new way of making it is needed, with constituencies ready before emergent institutions take shape.
Ideas: Invest in constituencies so they are ready to shape emergent institutions, with young people given a place in their governance. Build new place-based financial flows and local governance of resources.
The global knowledge commons2 cards
Every action about climate is ultimately about increasing the cooling capacity of the planet; global cooling is built into all the IPCC models and is the core of what the Collaborative is about. The core is a way to operationalise a knowledge commons, essential to institutional change and to protecting and preserving the capacity to implement solutions, through what the Collaborative is all about: stewardship. Each member is a knowledge steward of data and information, solutions and frameworks, people and expertise, and in some cases finance. The technology now exists to build a global commons from distributed networks: place-based stewards, contributors, and collective owners generate the knowledge, aggregated into biophysical and socioeconomic regions, since bioregions also function in socioeconomic conditions. That is the foundational level, the soil and the nutrients, layered across sectors, with learning flowing across regions like a mycelial network. Because the whole system is duplicated across regions, knowledge deleted in one place survives elsewhere. The Collaborative could be the steward of a global knowledge commons focused on solutions that can cool the planet.
K1Regional knowledge systems held in stewardship
Noticing: Each member is a knowledge steward of data, solutions, people, expertise, and in some cases finance, and that stewardship is held apart; knowledge is a source of power, prestige, and prosperity, so where it is held is a systems question. Only in the last couple of years has the technology existed to run a distributed knowledge system at global scale, with place-based stewards as its contributors and collective owners.
Why now: The technology to run a distributed knowledge system at global scale has existed only in the last couple of years.
Ideas: Regions need not be administrative districts: an Indigenous territory can be one, regions can overlap, and a biophysical region such as the Thames basin holds several sub-regions. Also: prototyping the commons inside the Collaborative's own network with existing tools, and disseminating knowledge and stories through the commons. A 2018 schematic for the Drawdown Coalition, since forked into the Global Solutions Alliance, is waiting to be activated.
K7Global commons infrastructure
Noticing: Knowledge is already being weaponised and is disappearing, and most knowledge systems will soon be centrally controlled. A global commons infrastructure, duplicated across regions so that deletion in one place is survivable, is counter-infrastructure for knowledge, with justice, equity, and inclusion built into its design because no single part can control it.
Why now: Knowledge is already being weaponised and is disappearing, and most knowledge systems will soon be centrally controlled. There is a window to build the commons now at relatively low cost, though maintaining the nodes would be a large project.
Ideas: Build regional nodes duplicated across partners, so that deletion in one place does not destroy the whole. Add an open-source structure other alliances can copy, legal and licensing frameworks for regional commons governance, and local or regional control of data. Knowledge alone does not get solutions implemented, so finance and political-opportunity strands need building beside it.
Enquiry areas — Budapest Day 3 (18)
A1Enabling mutualism in EU-Africa relations
Noticing: Win-win partnerships in EU-Africa relations are not win-win: there is almost always a winner and a loser, trust is missing on both sides, and EU strategies are scattered and built on transfer. Mutualism is the shift, a practice and a paradigm that can spread across the interfaces where members are already present, with the Critical Raw Materials Act and the EU policy cycle as the opening.
Why now: The geopolitical moment is acute. The EU and Africa not working together means both lose a critical counterweight, and existing EU strategies are scattered and focused on transfer. There is an opening in EU policy cycles and the Critical Raw Materials Act to shape something different before those frameworks calcify.
Why us: The Collaborative is present at many EU-Africa interfaces at once. It can identify the blockages, barriers, and hidden handbrakes to mutualism, gather evidence, stack solutions, and tell stories of change.
Ideas: Cluster existing work around a mutualism frame: the African Strategic Minerals Initiative, Policy Impact Labs, the African Cities Mission, and the Circular Supply Chain Coalition. Engage the Critical Raw Materials Act.
A2Export credit agencies and public finance for fossil projects
Noticing: Pledges to end public finance for fossil projects have not become action, and export credit agencies keep using public money for them. Members who engage the financiers from different angles are able to push them to act.
Why now: In 2021 EU and other global north countries pledged to end public finance for fossil fuels, and the pledges have yet to become action, while cuts to development aid tighten funding.
Why us: Members sit at both ends: one works with frontline communities in Ghana and has traced the public financiers behind fossil projects, another engages the financiers directly.
Ideas: Document and share frontline experience from Ghana, amplify it through the EU and the European Parliament and with the financiers, press the home government in parallel, and push for banks' complaints mechanisms to be made public.
A3Critical minerals and just transition
Noticing: The scramble for critical minerals is set to repeat the extractive relationship as geopolitical pressure grows. The African Strategic Minerals Initiative and the circular supply chain work are already in motion, so this is where a different relationship could be proven.
Why now: The geopolitical moment makes this a timely opening between the EU and Africa; the Critical Raw Materials Act is live policy to inform, and Ghana's lithium royalty is under renegotiation after a drop from 10 to 5 per cent.
Why us: The African Strategic Minerals Initiative and the Policy Impact Labs are only just starting, so there is room to shape them, alongside the African Cities Mission, the Just Cities Working Group, and the Circular Supply Chain Coalition, with members working on critical raw materials in Ghana.
Ideas: Build on the African Strategic Minerals Initiative.
A4Skills development and technology transfer for the green transition
Noticing: Skills programmes transfer skills without building them locally: in one training programme, trainees were not trained to train others and local artisans were not partners, so the knowledge did not stay. What is wanted instead is skills that meet local labour demand, local trainers, and technology transfer that refines what local artisans already make.
Why now: The EU market sets high standards while the continent lacks the technical skills to match them, and the mining and green-transition jobs promised to communities need skills local people do not yet have.
Why us: Members have first-hand knowledge of the German-Ghana training programme and its weaknesses, including work on decolonising GIZ, and development cooperation experience.
Ideas: Train trainers so skills spread; work with local artisans to adapt and fabricate technology; avoid fly-in experts who need ongoing funding; apply solar-installation training to agricultural mechanisation such as storage and post-harvest handling.
H1Community-led planetary health infrastructure
Noticing: States are retreating from health investment, and the most climate-vulnerable areas have the greatest shortage of health workers, the first responders to heat stress, outbreaks, and mental health impacts. Wanting to care for the ill and wounded outlasts almost every other attribute of civilisation, and community-led models already exist: cellular structures in Bangladesh and India, kinship networks in Africa, cooperatives in western North Carolina.
Why now: Health is one of the least politically divisive levers. The most climate-vulnerable areas also have the greatest shortage of healthcare workers, who are the first responders to heat stress, outbreaks, and mental health impacts. Community-led health infrastructure creates the politics of resilience and survival that carries communities through the transition: lose this and the resilience of society is lost, so build a peer-to-peer planetary response model.
Why us: Members already hold pieces of it: WHO connections, youth-led health organisations in the Global South, climate litigation, and frontline community work.
Ideas: Build a planetary network of small, community-led and community-owned health and wellbeing units, drawing on models in Bangladesh, India, Africa, and western North Carolina.
H2The future value of being human
Noticing: Humans are being devalued in terms of labour productivity and consumption, faster as AI displaces employment, and with it the case for state investment in health, education, and welfare. What is emerging is the argument for valuing human life beyond productivity, drawing on contemplative traditions, epigenetics, distributed intelligence, and interdependence with nature, with health infrastructure as one vehicle.
Why now: As the value of human labour falls, states find it harder to justify investment in health, education, and welfare. This is the underlying battle.
Why us: The Collaborative spans the philosophical, political, legal, health, and community sides of the question. Members already work on life-centred AI and alternative economic frameworks.
Ideas: Build the political, cultural, and economic conditions for valuing human life beyond productivity, with health infrastructure as one vehicle.
H3Fossil fuels as health-harming products
Noticing: Fossil fuels are still treated as a product of development and security, and the industry's stated agenda is to stop the litigation that names their harm. Naming a product as health-harming and getting that into law has led to taxes, levies, and finance for alternatives before, with tobacco, asbestos, and lead, and 58% of climate litigation already argues from health.
Why now: 58% of current climate litigation already uses health as its primary argument, and the fossil fuel industry's stated agenda is to stop it. When something is named as health-harming, regulation follows. Environmental health connects with people across the political spectrum, and naming health harm in law triggers risk assessments that change what investors will finance.
Why us: The mix of scientific, legal, community-grounded, and global reach this needs is rare. The commission work in Geneva is already beginning.
Ideas: Formalise the causal link between hydrocarbons and health damage; use it to free up funds for alternatives; bring the big oil states in to lead with their sovereign funds.
I1Institutions that marry participation and leadership
Noticing: Most institutions tend to maintain the status quo, representative institutions as currently constituted are not adequate for the work at hand, and trust in them is eroding. What is emerging is a different model, institutions for the transition that marry broad participation and leadership, with agency coming closer to communities.
Why now: Every crisis, whether a tipping point or a shock, needs alternatives ready before the moment arrives. Agency has to come closer to communities.
Why us: The Collaborative is already present in concrete places with track records, and can act as a membrane between civil society and institutions.
Ideas: Accompany the institutions and projects the Collaborative already works with, and learn what conditions they need to function.
I2Civic participation and agency
Noticing: Constituencies are losing the agency to hold institutions to account, and when they do, institutions become almost unable to adapt. Getting knowledge, data, and information to constituencies gives them the agency to protect and redefine what comes next.
Why now: The space for civic expression is shrinking, voice has been given without power, and institutions are losing legitimacy fast; when collapse comes, alternatives have to exist already.
Why us: Members support civic leaders and youth movements around the world, and the Collaborative is placed to build the long-term intermediary structures civic groups need, as a membrane between civil society and institutions.
Ideas: Get constituencies the knowledge, data, and information they need to protect and redefine institutions. Build intermediary structures, cooperatives among them, on the five enabling conditions found across civic wins in 30 countries: knowledge, peer-to-peer exchange, funding, leadership and capacity building, and political opportunities.
I3A distributed knowledge commons
Noticing: In a few years most data, information, and knowledge systems will be run by other entities, their AIs, and their government handlers, and open data as a default is no longer safe. A distributed commons, federated so that data deleted in one country is already held elsewhere, is possible now while the will and the technology are present; Indigenous people perceive the idea of the commons as very risky, so it needs guardrails.
Why now: The window for building resilient knowledge infrastructure is now, while the cost is low and the will is present. Once centralised and captured, it is extremely hard to recover.
Why us: Several members already work on distributed knowledge infrastructure and life-aligned AI. Each project can build tools that enter the commons.
Ideas: A federated, steward-led commons that protects Indigenous knowledge: if data is deleted in one country, partners elsewhere already hold it.
F1The rocket: a currency backed by living capital
Noticing: Blended finance has failed where it was tried, there is not enough public or philanthropic capital in the world to fund what has to happen, and the money that is minted goes to the global north. At the same time, central banks and sovereign states, Palau and Bhutan among them, are open to alternative currencies, the technology to model living systems is arriving, and 35 million hectares held in stewardship by Indigenous nations is a pilot already standing.
Why now: The current economic construct leaves off its ledger the things whose destruction will eventually collapse the economy, and the scale of what is needed cannot be funded from public or philanthropic capital alone. Palau, Bhutan, and a number of central banks have expressed interest in alternative currencies, and the Global South is already saying the system is rigged. AI is starting to make it possible to model interconnected living systems, though not yet at scale.
Why us: Members have direct experience with alternative finance mechanisms and pilots. A network of Indigenous nations stewarding 35 million hectares is a prime pilot.
Ideas: Two tracks: keep mobilising blended finance within the current system, and build a currency pegged to living systems, the rocket, on a timeline of about a thousand days.
R1The applied policy lab
Noticing: The corporate engagement model of the last ten years, built on voluntary declarations, is over, treating all private sector actors as equivalent helps no one, and policy-washing has joined greenwashing. Businesses willing to move say they need certainty about where regulation is going, and that is what a rules-based, applied policy process can give them.
Why now: Businesses say they need certainty about where regulation is going. The window for shaping transition-critical policy is open while deregulation accelerates.
Why us: The Collaborative spans organisations with very different relationships to business and can convene without a fixed public position to defend. Its applied projects give it credibility.
Ideas: Set up an applied policy lab: a structured process that convenes companies, NGOs, governments, and affected communities around specific policy questions, using existing projects as testing grounds. It would produce public written positions and monitor progress against commitments, and companies that bring inadequate proposals would lose their seat. Alongside it, a litigation fund aimed at directors and pension funds, and the question of whether a sunset fund should sit beside it; both are open.
R2Employee engagement as transition infrastructure
Noticing: Employee voice as a political and economic force is almost entirely untapped by the transition field. 3.7 billion people are at work, looking for meaning and at the front line of seeing both problems and solutions, and most do not know where to start.
Why now: Employee voice as a political and economic force is almost entirely untapped by the transition field.
Why us: Members already run platforms and training that reach thousands of employees a year, and hold a collective presence in the private sector that has not been mobilised jointly.
Ideas: Use law and organising to help employees influence policy and press their own employers.
C1From defence to offence on narrative
Noticing: A well-resourced counter-narrative with the status quo on its side recycles a small set of stories, and it is working; the field has been playing it safe, worried about manipulation. The opposition's coordination can be matched with the same tools, film, television, and social media, moving from defence to offence.
Why now: Narrative is the enabling condition for everything else, and people needed for the transition are being lost to nihilism or captured by counter-narratives.
Why us: The Collaborative holds organisations working on documentary, storytelling, health communication, and community organising, across places where narratives differ.
Ideas: Move from defence to offence, using the tools the opposition uses: film, television, and social media. A bearing-witness infrastructure (oral history, forensic documentation, visual record) as both a narrative and a legal strategy.
C2Bottom-up narratives: equipping messengers and storytellers
Noticing: The word climate is toxic in many contexts, and narrative delivered from above has fed the backlash. Billions of narratives already exist in communities; what lands is local, tangible, and tied to things people already love, and Danish activists are being elected by talking about local food, heat, and floods.
Why now: The field produces narrative content but underinvests in the conditions that let narratives emerge from communities.
Why us: The Collaborative works across geographies where the field's default language does not land.
Ideas: Find existing messengers and storytellers and equip them with skills, platforms, and reach. Health is a strong entry point.
L1AI, technology and the technological era
Noticing: AI in the United States is "the wild, wild west": a bill with no regulation for ten years, which may not stand, and big layoffs at the large technology companies. The same technology could be aligned with all of life, and members are already working on AI that is not blind to it.
Why now: A US bill sets no regulation for ten years, which may not stand, while mass layoffs are under way; Europe is pushing for sovereignty over its technology stack, Ghana is drafting AI regulation, and the current systems risk entrenching colonial and capitalist patterns.
Why us: Members are already working to make AI life-aligned so that externalities are not a thing, introducing AI in agriculture and education in Africa, and holding positions in Brussels and Silicon Valley.
Ideas: How to align AI with all of life, and how to shape the next technological era. The aim: "Earth-centred AI that augments civilisation's ability to foster planetary resilience".
L2Create, close, and reform the institutions we need for the new world
Noticing: Some institutions will not be needed, some need creating, and most need changing: create, close, and reform the institutions the new world needs.
Why now: Mistrust in institutions is poison for crisis response, and there is a clear deadline from climate and technology: a mistake now cannot be corrected.
Why us: Localism, institutional reform, and mutualism already run through many positions, with track records in North Carolina and Ireland, and the ecological and knowledge commons are something all members take part in.
Ideas: Combine participation, leadership, and institutions of transition so the change is firm without being a revolution; build the scaffolding that holds institutions while they are rebuilt; steward a distributed, collectively owned knowledge commons.
O1Intergenerational collaboration
Noticing: The places where generations used to meet are closing. Generations divide less once they gather around a shared interest, and young people, the biggest demographic able to respond to unemployment, climate, and health, will be leading governments within five or six years.
Why now: Young people are the biggest demographic able to respond to the crises of unemployment, climate, and health, and will be leading governments within five or six years.
Why us: Members already hold working models: a school that pairs six months of teaching with six months of internship with a tribal leader, scenario work that bridges generations, and a youth-led fund with an advisory board of experts. Surface these across the portfolio before proposing anything new.
Ideas: Four moves: surface what members already do on intergenerational work and bring it into the portfolio; consider it in how the Collaborative operates; explore a position on the bigger dynamics, such as employment, social protection, and public employment tied to nature; and build it into existing positions such as the bioregional work and Beyond 1.5. The Green Jobs Guild fits a little in both.
Candidate positions (24)
Draft positions for the next round as the portfolio team stated them. Grade records how far each was stated by the team vs. inferred by the tool — hover it for the note.
| # | Position | Statement | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| CP01 | Fossil fuels as a health-harming product | Go where naming fossil fuels as health-harming, in law and in finance, turns their harm into regulation, levies, and investor risk. | stated |
| CP02 | Civic infrastructure connecting participation with institutions | Go where isolated democratic breakthroughs can become a lasting middle between civic action and institutions. | inferred |
| CP03 | Institutions of transition: create, close, reform, and be ready | Go where the institutions that hold the system are losing legitimacy, and can be reformed, closed, or newly created when a window opens. | stated |
| CP04 | New vectors of power | Go where power is moving to new constituencies, employees, health workers, young people, and business, and their influence can be organised before the old holders have gone. | inferred |
| CP05 | Bioregional governance and finance, a blueprint that travels | Go where the bioregion is the scale at which governance, finance, and ecological knowledge can be brought together, and what works in one region can travel to others. | current |
| CP06 | Cities and urban transformation: from plans to financeable projects | Go where cities' climate commitments outrun their capacity to deliver, and the gap between plans and financeable projects can close. | current |
| CP07 | From ownership to stewardship | Go where land tenure decides what can be restored, and ownership can give way to stewardship as Indigenous nations already practise it. | stated |
| CP08 | The Two Basins, Amazon and Congo, held back from tipping | Go where the Amazon and Congo basins are nearing their tipping point, and their collapse can still be prevented. | inferred |
| CP09 | An earth currency and sovereign fund backed by living capital | Go where money backed by living systems, rather than by nation-state currencies, can turn finance toward what it depends on. | stated |
| CP10 | Resilience as an investible asset class | Go where ecological resilience and water security are not yet priced, and can become an asset class ahead of the market. | current |
| CP11 | Cooling and caring | Go where heat is the pressure everyone feels, and cooling with care can be the entry to the transition for cities and the places most exposed. | inferred |
| CP12 | Community-led planetary health infrastructure | Go where states are retreating from health and the most exposed places have the fewest health workers, and community-led care can become the resilience infrastructure. | stated |
| CP13 | A distributed knowledge commons that survives capture | Go where knowledge is being centralised and weaponised, and a federated commons held by place-based stewards can survive deletion in any one place. | inferred |
| CP14 | Narrative from defence to offence, with local messengers | Go where the counter-narrative is winning and the field plays safe, and narrative can move from defence to offence through the messengers who already exist. | current |
| CP15 | An earth consciousness movement | Go where a crisis of belonging can become the moment an earth consciousness movement catches, anchored in the worldview of Indigenous nations. | stated |
| CP16 | Critical minerals and just transition at the EU-Africa interface | Go where the transition's minerals and materials are being decided as extractive or equitable, at the EU-Africa interface where the rules are still being written. | current |
| CP17 | Food, water, and ecological stability institutions where the multilaterals fail | Go where international systems cannot be assumed to hold, and stability institutions for food, water, and ecological security can form at the scale of middle powers, cities, and regions. | stated |
| CP18 | Partnering with, or hacking, the military | Go where military and security spending is rising and militaries carry climate exposure of their own, and common cause on risk, peace, and climate can bend the largest rising budgets toward resilience. | stated |
| CP19 | Energy communities and energy democracy | Go where energy bills are driving people to anger, and energy communities can become infrastructure people own and the entry point for people power. | stated |
| CP20 | Life-aligned AI | Go where AI is being built without regulation or alignment to life, and AI aligned with life can run the infrastructures of transition. | inferred |
| CP21 | Regenerative agriculture | Go where European agricultural policy and smallholder agrobiodiversity in the Global South are both in transition, and regenerative agriculture can take hold in both at once. | inferred |
| CP22 | Rules and incentives for business | Go where the voluntary-declaration era of corporate engagement has ended, and rules and incentives can give willing businesses certainty about where regulation is going. | inferred |
| CP23 | Prosperity and the good life beyond GDP | Go where faith in the future is thinning and GDP still defines a good life, and societies deliberating what prosperity means can reset the measures that policy answers to. | inferred |
| CP24 | People power, culture, and movement building | Go where people can be mobilised en masse through what they already belong to, energy, faith, work, and culture, and people power can become the infrastructure the transition is under-building. | stated |
Sources of hypothesis and design22
- Positive tipping points — Changes that, once activated, create an upward lift towards new futures: regenerative agriculture or the circular economy taking off, a shift in mindset spreading through narrative or faith. Human systems tip the same way physical ones do. They are the hypotheses of the frame, and its imagination space: where a shift is close to tipping, a push can carry it over, and conditions in some places are readier than others to set new standards.
- Negative tipping points — Shifts in earth and social systems that become irreversible once crossed, with cascading effects across the global system. Science tracks 28 global regime shifts, among them the Amazon turning to savannah, the collapse of the Atlantic current, and the failure of several breadbaskets at once; social systems show the same signals of disruption when they are about to change phase, as in collapsing trust in institutions. Each can be traced back to its drivers, and to the places and value chains behind them. That is where intervention points are found, and where a crisis opens institutions to change.
- Amazon dieback: forest to savannah — A tipping element of the biosphere, and one of the four case studies of the Global Tipping Points Report 2025: past a threshold of deforestation and drying, the Amazon stops making its own rain and converts to savannah, releasing carbon and shifting rainfall across South America. One of the 28 regime shifts science tracks, on a horizon of about eight years.
- Collapse of the Atlantic circulation — A tipping element of ocean circulation, and a case study of the Global Tipping Points Report 2025: the Atlantic current that carries heat north weakens past a threshold and shuts down, undermining food and water security and plunging northern Europe into severe winters. A new paper puts the chance of collapse this century at 50 per cent, double the figure the health and climate commission worked with a year ago; the WHO has named it a tipping point issue for health for the first time.
- Loss of warm-water coral reefs — The first tipping point crossed: the Global Tipping Points Report 2025 finds warm-water coral reefs passing their thermal threshold and dying back at unprecedented scale, taking with them the fisheries, coastal protection, and livelihoods of hundreds of millions of people. Named with the Amazon and the Atlantic circulation among the bigger regime shifts.
- Mountain glacier loss: the Himalaya and the Alps — A tipping element of the cryosphere, and a case study of the Global Tipping Points Report 2025: mountain glaciers pass the point where they can regrow, and the rivers they feed swing from flood to shortage. The Himalayan cascade sits in the lives of 3.8 billion people, where the political conditions cannot drive the innovation needed; the Alps and Santiago's glaciers are the same system in places that can act.
- Multi-breadbasket failure — A cascade, not a single element, listed by the tipping-points group at playback and not discussed. What the Mind the Gap room said: food supply is at risk now, with fertiliser shortages, falling reserves, and the Strait of Hormuz; a food and water stability board on the model of the Financial Stability Board, possibly as a mid-tier structure of middle powers; biohubs; a submission to the UN report on food and human rights.
- Heat beyond the habitable in cities — An impact threshold, not an earth system element: cities cross the heat and humidity levels at which bodies, labour, and infrastructure stop functioning, and the damage is already built into every IPCC model whatever the economy does. Heat in major cities, health problems, and the disruption of essential infrastructure are the inevitable consequences the cooling and caring work starts from.
- Multilateral institutions losing capacity and trust — A social tipping point, negative: trust in institutions erodes past the point where they can act, and the loss feeds itself. International systems cannot be assumed to hold; no one is listening at the UN; the WHO is not made for tipping point logic and is incredibly vulnerable; most institutions tend to maintain the status quo as trust in them drains.
- Political backlash against climate action — A social tipping point, negative: once climate policy arrives without citizens' authorship, each reversal makes the next easier, and the word itself turns toxic. The EU political environment has shifted decisively against climate action; policy that bypasses communities is reversed in the next election cycle and feeds populist rejection; policymakers are scared to take any transformative action.
- Labour and the value of being human displaced by AI — A social tipping point, negative: as AI displaces employment, the case for valuing people by productivity and consumption collapses, and with it the case for state investment in health, education, and welfare. AI in the United States runs without regulation and with large layoffs at the technology companies; the battle line is the future value of being human.
- Knowledge centralised and weaponised — A social tipping point, negative, in the information feedbacks a society runs on: within a few years most data and knowledge systems will be run by entities whose interests are not aligned with the transition, knowledge is already being weaponised and deleted, and open data as a default is no longer safe.
- Regenerative agriculture taking off — A positive tipping point in land use: once enough farmers in a region shift, knowledge, markets, and soil recovery reinforce one another and the practice spreads on its own. The mechanisms for agri-food transition already exist and are poorly coordinated; localised regenerative agriculture is the longer-term answer on food, with near-term equitable distribution as the bridge.
- Circular industrial value chains — A positive tipping point in industry: once a value chain is redesigned around reuse and regeneration and the cost falls below extraction, the rest of the industry follows. Whole industries still run on extraction through production, consumption, and waste; the New Mexico minerals supply chain shows one being transformed from a place.
- Fossil fuels reframed as health-harming products — A positive tipping point in norms and law: categorising a product as harmful starts the process of regulating it, and the precedent is tobacco, asbestos, and lead, which went from accepted to taxed, labelled, and litigated once the health harm was named. Energy is health positive; fossil fuels are health-harming; 58 per cent of climate litigation now argues from health, and the industry's priority is to stop it.
- Decentralised renewable energy and energy communities — The positive tipping points the Global Tipping Points Report 2025 finds already crossed and reinforcing each other: solar power and electric vehicles accelerating worldwide as costs fall below the incumbents. Each community that owns its energy makes the next one easier; energy bills are driving people to anger over infrastructure that is not theirs, and forming an energy community saves money and gives them a real infrastructure to hold.
- Fossil assets repriced: divestment and doubt — A positive tipping point in financial markets: once enough investors treat carbon assets as risk, divestment reinforces the belief that drives it and capital moves faster than policy. ESG ratings still let oil and gas score highly, and export credit agencies still put public money into fossil projects while pledges to stop go unmet.
- Mindset shifts through narrative, faith, and belonging — A positive tipping point in norms and values: a few messengers with reach can shift what a population takes as normal, and the shift spreads through the networks people already belong to. The word climate is toxic in many places and fear-driven communication has failed for two decades; what lands is local and tied to what people love; faith communities hold trust and reach the field rarely engages; an earth consciousness movement is budding, and the crisis of belonging is its moment.
- Participation tipping politics: the Hungarian election — Not named as a tipping point in any transcript. Hungary appears in the Budapest rooms as the Peace Islands work and as the live case for connecting civic participation with institutions (cards K4, K5).
- From ownership to stewardship — A positive tipping point in law and norms: once one jurisdiction recognises stewardship, rights of nature, or land held in trust, others follow the precedent, and the alternative already exists in the Indigenous nations who hold their bioregions. Who owns land decides what can be restored; the power structures holding the system rest on ownership of land, companies, and ideas.
- Currencies backed by living capital — A hypothesis of a positive tipping point in money, the Collaborative's own: a currency grounded in living systems, which AI is starting to make possible to model. The card says there is not enough public or philanthropic capital in the world to fund what has to happen, and that Palau, Bhutan, and several central banks have expressed interest in alternative currencies (card F1).
- A distributed knowledge commons, possible now — A positive tipping point in information feedbacks: once knowledge flows between places as a commons, learning compounds across regions and the arrows between every other area accelerate. Only in the last couple of years has the technology existed to run a distributed knowledge system at global scale, and every member is already a knowledge steward.
_sources/claude-artifacts/). The proposed canonical vocabulary is in vocabulary.md.